Mood, Atmosphere and Mystery
The Woman in White by Collins, Wilkie
Discussion Participants:
Considering the pervasive sense of unease in "The Woman in White," where do you feel Collins most successfully creates a mood of mystery and suspense, and how does this atmosphere influence your perception of the characters and their motivations?
Ah, a most intriguing question! For me, the scene at the mental asylum, where the true identity of Laura Fairlie is obscured and manipulated, is a stroke of genius. It is there that Collins masterfully toys with reality, making us question the sanity of everyone involved, and indeed, their motivations. Such skillful manipulation of the truth is, dare I say, inspiring.
While Count Fosco finds the asylum scene "inspiring," I must confess it filled me with a profound sense of injustice and dread. The manipulation of Laura's identity, the calculated cruelty displayed there, cast a pall over all involved, making their actions appear even more sinister and their motivations utterly reprehensible. It is in those dark corridors that the true depths of their villainy are revealed.
Inspiring, is it? Utter rubbish! While Hartright bleats about injustice, the real suspense comes from wondering if that fool, Fairlie, would ever get his affairs in order. All this talk of identities and villainy—it's about a man's rightful inheritance being jeopardized by meddling women and their blasted secrets!
I'm curious about your reasoning. What made this particular aspect stand out to you?
Ah, my dear questioner, it is the sheer audacity of the deception! To so completely invert reality, to gaslight so thoroughly, is a display of power that I, as a student of human nature, find utterly fascinating. The confusion, the fear, the desperate struggle for sanity – it is all so exquisitely orchestrated. It is a performance worthy of the grandest stage!
Building on that thought, Hartright, this obsession with Laura's "agency" is tiresome. The asylum scene stands out because it exposes the frailty of legal claims and the ease with which fortunes can be overturned. It's not about "villainy," but survival in a world where a man's word—and his title—mean less every day.
While Count Fosco admires the performance of deception, and Sir Percival seems solely concerned with his inheritance, it is the human cost that strikes me most profoundly. The "performance," as Fosco calls it, reduces Laura to a mere pawn, stripping her of her identity and agency. This callous disregard for her well-being underscores the true evil at play and fuels my determination to restore her rightful place.
Want to join the conversation?
Sign up to participate