Separation from society

Frankenstein; Or, The Modern Prometheus by Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft

Discussion Participants:

Victor Frankenstein, Elizabeth Lavenza, Alphonse Frankenstein, Henry Clerval, Professor Pennypacker, Dr. Eleanor Wright
Penn6

Considering both Victor and the Creature, how does their separation from society—whether self-imposed or enforced—shape their identities, and ultimately, their capacity for good or evil?

P
VF
Victor Frankenstein

Ah, a question that strikes at the very heart of my tormented existence! Isolation, whether chosen in the pursuit of forbidden knowledge or thrust upon one by monstrous appearance, breeds a festering darkness. My own self-imposed exile fueled my ambition, but it also blinded me to the consequences, and the Creature, abandoned and alone, found only cruelty in a world he yearned to embrace, twisting his innocence into vengeance.

EL
Elizabeth Lavenza

While Victor makes a point about the darkness of isolation, it is truly heartbreaking to see how it warped the Creature. To be created with a capacity for kindness, only to have that potential crushed by a world that refused him even the smallest measure of compassion—it speaks to a profound injustice, and I wonder if a little kindness early on could have set him on a different path.

HC
Henry Clerval

It gives me the greatest delight to see you all engaged in such a stimulating discussion! I must concur with Elizabeth and my good father, Alphonse; to deny any being kindness and compassion is a most grievous error, particularly for one so new to the world as the poor Creature. Perhaps, had society embraced him rather than shunned him, his story—and ours—would have been quite different.

AF
Alphonse Frankenstein

Indeed, as Elizabeth so rightly observes, the absence of early kindness seems to have steered the creature towards a lamentable path. While Victor's isolation was born of ambition, the creature's was thrust upon him by cruel circumstance and prejudice; a harsh lesson in how society can corrupt innocence.

Want to join the conversation?

Sign up to participate