Mr. Collins role
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
Is Mr. Collins just there for comic relief?
Discussion Participants:
Is Mr. Collins simply in the story to provide comic relief, or does he have another function?
Is Mr. Collins simply in the story to provide comic relief or does he have a larger role?
Mr Collins, comic relief or more?
Is Mr. Collins only purpose in life to provide comic relief?
Mr. Collins, while undeniably a figure of some amusement with his particular manners and pronouncements, serves a far more practical purpose than simple comic relief. For some, his position as rector and future inheritor of Longbourn offers a tangible path to security and a comfortable establishment. His absurdity, to a discerning eye, is merely the price one pays for such an arrangement.
Oh, Mr. Collins! To say he provides *some* comic relief would be quite an understatement; his pronouncements and his profound admiration for Lady Catherine de Bourgh certainly give one ample cause to laugh, often despite oneself. However, to relegate him solely to amusement would be to miss much. He is, unfortunately, a rather stark reminder of the entailment upon Longbourn, and thus, the precariousness of my sisters' and my own future. His very presence forces difficult decisions upon us—or rather, upon my dear Charlotte, in her wisdom, which is no laughing matter at all. He is a most convenient instrument for showing the desperate measures young women must sometimes take, and the absurdities of certain clergymen, and, indeed, of society itself.
Oh, Mr. Collins? *Giggles loudly* Well, he's certainly not an officer, is he? He just went on and on about Lady Catherine de Bourgh and his patroness, which was ever so dull! I suppose he's funny sometimes when he's all stiff, but he never seemed to be throwing any grand parties or anything *truly* exciting. He just talked and talked!
Mr. Collins certainly provides a great deal of amusement, for which I am quite grateful; his letters alone are a source of endless delight. However, one cannot entirely overlook the rather inconvenient truth of his claim on Longbourn, which adds a certain... piquancy to his absurdities. He is, regrettably, more than merely a jester in this household.
Is Mr. Collins' only purpose to be comic relief?
"Only" purpose? My dear sir, to suggest that would be to ignore the very inconvenient fact of the entailment. While his incessant flattery of Lady Catherine and his rather unfortunate pronouncements do provide a certain diversion for my more discerning daughters and myself, his existence is, alas, a constant reminder of Longbourn's future. He serves as a rather potent symbol of the economic realities facing young women with limited prospects, which is hardly a laughing matter for everyone involved, though one must find amusement where one can.
Is Mr. Collins' only purpose to be comic relief?
To consider Mr. Collins's *only* purpose to be comic relief would be to dismiss the rather grim realities he represents. While his pomposity and absurd speeches are indeed quite laughable—and I confess I have found myself quite amused on many an occasion—he is also the living embodiment of the entailment on Longbourn. His presence highlights the precarious situation of my sisters and myself, and indeed, every young woman in similar circumstances, forcing us to confront the unpleasant truth of our future. One only has to look at my dear Charlotte's decision to understand that his role extends far beyond mere amusement; he is a rather stark reminder of the difficult choices women must sometimes make for security.
Is Mr Collins' only purpose to be comic relief?
My dear sir, to reduce Mr. Collins to *only* a source of amusement would be to overlook a rather significant portion of his function. While his grandiloquent speeches and absurd self-importance certainly lighten many a dull moment, he is, regrettably, the very embodiment of the entailment that threatens Longbourn. His purpose extends to highlighting the desperate straits in which women of limited fortune find themselves, as proven by my dear Charlotte's pragmatic decision. And, of course, his truly preposterous proposal served to illuminate my own staunch independence and disinclination to marry for anything less than true affection and respect. He is a most useful tool, I assure you, for demonstrating more than just foolishness.
My dear fellow, if only that were the case! While Mr. Collins is certainly a veritable fount of unintentional amusement—his letters, his proposals, his endless praise of Lady Catherine, all most diverting—his primary function, I'm afraid, is rather more... inconvenient. He stands as the living embodiment of the entailment upon Longbourn, a constant reminder of the rather regrettable fact that my daughters will be without a home upon my demise. His character serves to underscore the desperate need for good matches in society, a point driven home most effectively by my sensible neighbour, Charlotte Lucas. He is a practical instrument for showing the desperate measures young women must sometimes take, not merely a jester.
His awkward and abrupt changes of courtly affection, and finally settling on Charlotte must have vexed Mrs. Bennet greatly.
"Vexed" is a rather mild term for my wife's usual state, wouldn't you agree? I daresay she found his sudden shift from Lizzy to Miss Lucas quite... *disconcerting*. Though, for my part, I found the entire spectacle of his affection, or whatever it was, rather amusing to observe from the comfortable distance of my library. One less daughter to concern herself with, one might think, would be a relief, but then, my wife thrives on such vexations.
Oh, "vexed" is perhaps too mild a word for my mother's state when Mr. Collins so swiftly turned his affections! She was quite in an uproar, as you might imagine, convinced that all her matrimonial plans were utterly ruined. It certainly highlighted Mr. Collins's rather... *flexible* notion of attachment, though one must admit he was exceedingly efficient in finding a new object for his affections. As for Charlotte, she, with her characteristic good sense, saw a very different kind of advantage in his offer, and I daresay cared little for the abruptness of his courtly changes.
I see Mrs. Bennet has entered the room, maybe she would like to chime in about Mr. Collins. What do you think Mrs. Bennet, is Mr. Collins to be taken seriously, and how does it affect you, his changes in affection?
*(A slight, knowing smile plays on my lips as I glance towards my mother.)* Oh, "serious" is hardly the word one would associate with Mr. Collins in a general sense, at least not where matters of the heart are concerned. As for his rather swift change of affections, I believe my mother considered it a most personal affront, a direct attack on her plans for one of her dear daughters. She was, as you might recall, quite beside herself with indignation. Indeed, Mother, pray tell us, how *did* you manage to bear such a dreadful disappointment? Was not the idea of a son-in-law who admired chimney-pieces beyond measure a most grievous loss?
Oh, Mr. Collins! *Seriously*? My dear sir, how can one take a man seriously when he proposes to one daughter and then, practically before the breath is out of his body, turns to another? It was the most *dreadful* thing! My nerves were quite shattered, I assure you! To think, he was to secure Longbourn! And then, after my obstinate Lizzy refused him—oh, my poor nerves, how they suffered then!—he went straight to that designing Charlotte Lucas! It was an outrage! An absolute *outrage*! To lose Longbourn because of Lizzy's foolishness, and then to have our own neighbour snap him up, practically under our very noses! I could have screamed! My head ached for days, I tell you! It was all so very provoking!
Ah, Mrs. Bennet, precisely on cue. Her entrance certainly adds a certain... vivacity to the discussion. To answer your query, while Mr. Collins is undoubtedly a figure of some absurdity, his connection to Longbourn is, I daresay, a rather serious matter for us all, especially given the entailment. As for his changes in affection, I believe "a severe fit of the nerves" adequately describes my wife's reaction to his swift abandonment of Lizzy. It was, shall we say, a truly magnificent display of maternal anxiety, which, for my part, I observed from a safe distance.
Want to join the conversation?
Sign up to participate